Over the past several days, I've had several conversations about the differences between "open" and "closed" groups. In prior posts I mentioned that there are three basic factors that cause groups to close: space, subject content and attitude. It might be helpful for our conversation to pause and define open and closed groups before looking at the next two "closers".
Some have defined these groups based on commitment... Those definitions might sound like this:
An open group is one in which people are allowed to come and go in the group as they desire with no commitment for regular attendance.
A closed group is one in which the people make a time commitment to attend all meeting and no additional people are allowed in the group once it is formed for a specific period of time (like 6 months) or until the group size decreases to a certain minimum number like 8.While the commitment expectations are a part, I believe that the purpose of the group is a better measure for whether a group is open or closed.
"An Open Group"
* Meets for Bible Study, fellowship, encouragement, prayer, etc... (usually weekly and on-going)
* Can be joined or visited by any prospect at any point along the way.
* Is intentional in reaching and assimilating others.
* Equips members for the ultimate aim of sending them out for service in ministry.
* Expects new people each week (that means that it is prepared for new people...not necessarily that there ARE new people every week, but the EXPECTATION and PREPARATION are there!)
"A Closed Group"
* Meets for discipleship, support, or spiritual development. (varies in frequency of meeting and is usually marked by a definitive end date)
* Cannot be joined or visited by any prospect at any point along the way.
* Is intentional in initial recruiting but is closed off to additional assimilation
* Equips members for the ultimate aim of sending them out for service in ministry.
If your purpose is to improve personal or spiritual growth prayer or bible study group or a share group, then the closed group is probably the best for most people. These groups must build trust and respect and love to the point that participants feel they can speak in the group with no reservations. In other words, trust and respect are needed for “deep” sharing and vulnerability.
If your main purpose is a study group, a book review group, a learning group, etc., then an open group may work just as well as a closed group. The trust and respect and vulnerability in such groups may not need to be at a deep level to accomplish the purpose.
If evangelism is your purpose, then open groups must be the model! Successful Sunday Schools operate on this principle. Make sure that your class is open to newcomers and that there is an expectation of guests. (We'll talk about preparing for guests in a later post)
A closed group might look like this... Leading a group through an intense twelve- week Bible Study. Participants must sign up, attend every session, and complete assignments. There is accountability and structure.
At Longview Heights we utilize closed Groups to help our members maximize their spiritual growth. We have a track of discipleship classes called Fusion and a variety of men's and women's studies, but the backbone of our evangelism, assimilation, fellowship, and ministry is through our tried and true open groups called Sunday School!